The long-promised return of Julius and Vincent
If you have already read my breakdown of the Arnold Schwarzenegger Twins salary deal over on FlipTheMovieScript, you know Twins is the little PG-13 comedy that quietly became Arnold’s biggest payday. The natural follow-up question fans kept asking for years was simple: if that movie worked so well, why didn’t we ever get a sequel?
For a long time, the answer was, “It’s coming.” That sequel even had a title: Triplets. The plan was to bring back Julius and Vincent Benedict, then throw in a third brother nobody knew about. It sounded like exactly the kind of high-concept nonsense eighties kids would show up for as adults.
And for a while, it was very real. Scripts were written, casting was announced, and filming windows were circled on calendars. Then it all quietly died.
Where Triplets came from
The Triplets idea started making noise around 2012. The basic hook was perfect: Julius and Vincent discover they are not just twins, but part of a trio, with a third brother who somehow turned out even more different than the first two.
Director Ivan Reitman explained that the spark came after Arnold spent time with another comedy legend. According to Reitman, the thought was simple and very on brand.
“I should be a triplet, that could be a very funny comedy.”
Once that line existed, the sequel almost wrote itself. The studio liked the concept, Arnold and Danny DeVito were in, and Reitman was ready to come back to direct. The tone was meant to match the original: a gentle, slightly absurd family comedy that still lets Arnold send himself up a bit.
Eddie Murphy, then Tracy Morgan: who was the third brother?
For years, the big selling point of Triplets was the third name on the poster. The first version of the movie was built around Eddie Murphy joining Schwarzenegger and DeVito as the long-lost brother. Arnold talked about it openly in interviews, saying Eddie was absolutely involved and that everyone was excited.
“Everyone is happy to do this movie.”
That version stalled because Murphy’s schedule exploded again after Coming 2 America. When his dance card filled up, the production team reworked the script for another comic who could bring the same kind of chaotic energy. By 2021, the role officially moved to Tracy Morgan, with Deadline and others reporting that he would play the third Benedict brother and that filming was aiming for early 2022 in Boston.
On paper, it sounded like a fun evolution of the original joke. You would have:
-
Arnold as the engineered “perfect specimen” who still feels like an outsider
-
DeVito as the small-time hustler who can’t quite get out of his own way
-
Morgan as the wildcard brother dropped into the middle, reacting to these two weird opposites
The vibe was not gritty legacy sequel. It was older brothers, a new sibling, and a lot of denial about how any of this made sense genetically.
How Triplets was supposed to build on Twins
Story-wise, Triplets was not meant to blow up the original movie. It was meant to lean into it. Julius and Vincent would be older, crankier, and more set in their ways. The plot would revolve around the discovery that the genetic experiment behind their birth produced one more result the scientists never told anyone about.
That setup does what a good sequel should do. It lets you revisit the emotional core of the first film – two guys who were never meant to be brothers, figuring out what family means – and then stress test it. How do Julius and Vincent react when the universe hands them another sibling, one who may be less “perfect” on paper but more honest about who he is?
For fans who love digging into this kind of stuff, this is exactly the sort of project I flag in my Movie Facts Hub. It is not just trivia. It is a look at how Hollywood tries to bottle an old feeling and sell it to a new generation, sometimes decades after the first movie came out.
What killed Triplets and why it is officially dead
So, if the cast was set, the script was rewritten, and the money was lined up, what happened?
The turning point was Ivan Reitman’s death in 2022. He had been the creative anchor of both Twins and Triplets, and the person everyone trusted to keep the tone right. After he passed away, control over the project shifted, and that is where things fell apart.
Arnold has been very blunt about what happened next. In a later interview he said:
“Jason Reitman literally stopped the project when his father died.”
According to Arnold, they had financing in place, he wanted to do it, Danny DeVito wanted to do it, and Ivan had been enthusiastic. Once Ivan was gone, Jason Reitman decided he did not like the idea and put the brakes on for good.
From the outside, you can understand both sides. For the original team, Triplets was a chance to reunite old friends and pay off a long-teased sequel. For a son taking care of his father’s legacy, there is a real fear of turning a beloved, oddly gentle comedy into a late-career gimmick. Either way, the result is the same. Triplets is no longer in active development, and everyone involved now talks about it in the past tense.
What is left of the Benedict brothers
The good news is that Arnold and Danny are not done working together. Both have said they are developing another project, just not Triplets. The exact logline keeps shifting in interviews, but the energy is the same as it was back in 1988: two guys with wildly different body types and rhythms who genuinely like playing off each other.
In a way, that fits the legacy of Twins better than a sequel that arrived thirty-plus years later might have. The original movie already got its miracle: a huge box office run, a monster backend payoff, and a salary deal so wild I had to give it its own deep dive in my Arnold Schwarzenegger Twins salary deal article. Triplets would have been a victory lap. Instead, it is now one more Hollywood “what if” that lives in interviews, old scripts, and the heads of fans who still picture that Triplets poster that never quite existed.





